It's one of the most common questions in the crafting world: should I learn crochet or knitting first? Both use yarn. Both produce beautiful results. Both are wonderfully calming once you get into the rhythm. But they're quite different crafts — and for a beginner, choosing the right one can make all the difference to whether you fall in love with it or give up after a frustrating first evening.
Here's an honest comparison to help you decide.
The Basics: How Are They Different?
Knitting uses two needles and works with multiple live stitches at once. You build fabric by transferring loops from one needle to the other, row by row. The result tends to be stretchy and drapey — ideal for garments, socks, and anything you want to wear.
Crochet uses a single hook and works with one live stitch at a time. You build fabric by pulling loops through loops, stitch by stitch. The result is generally thicker and more structured — great for blankets, bags, toys, and home décor.
Which Is Easier to Learn?
Most beginners find crochet slightly easier to pick up. Here's why:
- You only ever have one live stitch on your hook at a time — so if you make a mistake, it's easier to spot and fix
- Dropped stitches (the bane of many a knitter's life) are much less of an issue
- The hook is easier to hold and manoeuvre than two needles
- Basic crochet stitches can be mastered in a single sitting
That said, knitting isn't difficult — it just has a slightly steeper initial learning curve. Many people find that once it clicks, it feels incredibly natural and meditative.
Which Produces Results Faster?
Crochet tends to work up more quickly. Crochet stitches are taller than knit stitches, which means your fabric grows faster — very satisfying when you're just starting out and want to see progress.
With knitting, smaller projects like dishcloths or hats are still very achievable for beginners, but the fabric builds more slowly stitch by stitch.
What Can You Make?
Knitting is particularly well suited to:
- Garments — jumpers, cardigans, tops
- Socks and gloves
- Scarves, hats, and cowls
- Lightweight, drapey shawls
Crochet is particularly well suited to:
- Blankets and throws
- Bags and baskets
- Amigurumi (crocheted toys and characters)
- Granny squares and patchwork projects
- Home décor
Both crafts overlap considerably — you can make hats, scarves, and shawls in either. But if you have a specific project in mind, it's worth thinking about which craft is better suited to it.
What Equipment Do You Need?
Knitting requires:
- A pair of needles (or circular needles for larger projects)
- Yarn
- A darning needle for finishing
Crochet requires:
- A single hook
- Yarn
- A darning needle for finishing
Crochet wins on simplicity here — one hook is easier to manage than two needles, and there's less to buy to get started. At Stitch Kit Shop, all the small equipment you need is included in every kit, so you don't have to worry about sourcing anything separately.
Which Is Better for Mindfulness?
Both crafts are genuinely meditative once you find your rhythm — but they offer slightly different experiences.
Knitting has a gentle, rocking rhythm that many people find deeply calming. The repetitive motion of transferring stitches can feel almost hypnotic, and it's easy to knit while listening to a podcast or watching television.
Crochet requires slightly more visual attention, particularly when following a pattern — but many crocheters describe it as wonderfully absorbing, the kind of focus that clears the mind of everything else.
Both are excellent antidotes to screen time.
So Which Should You Start With?
- Start with crochet if you want quick results, you're worried about dropping stitches, or you want to make blankets, toys, or structured items
- Start with knitting if you're drawn to garments and wearables, you love the idea of fine, drapey fabric, or you have a specific knitting project in mind
- Not sure? Our customer survey will help us point you in the right direction — just tell us what you'd like to make and we'll recommend the perfect starter kit
The honest truth is that many crafters end up doing both. They're complementary skills, and once you've learned one, the other comes more easily.
Ready to Pick Up Your First Kit?
At Stitch Kit Shop, every kit is handpicked and packed by hand, specifically for you. Whether you're drawn to crochet or knitting — or you'd like us to help you decide — fill out our customer survey and we'll take care of the rest.
Fill out our customer survey →
Browse our subscription kits →
Happy making — whichever you choose! 🧶